Understanding Ancient Chinese Justice and the Death Penalty

One of China’s oldest and most important systems is its criminal justice system. The death penalty has played a role in China’s justice system since the first legal code was established. But how did the death penalty become a part of Chinese justice and what has been the role of it in Chinese civilization?

Since the beginning of Chinese civilization, the death penalty has been an integral part of punishing those who have committed crimes. From the Qin Dynasty, who introduced the codified death penalty in the 3rd century BCE, to the Qing dynasty culminating in 1911, death sentences were severely implemented in China for a variety of offenses. What was the purpose of such harsh punishment? As the primary punishment for a crime, the death penalty was intended to be a deterrence, as well as sending a message to all citizens regarding the consequences of breaking the law and that the state would be the ultimate authority of justice.

In the traditional Chinese system, crime was taken quite seriously and the act of punishing criminals was seen as one of the most important duties of the government. The way in which the death penalty was carried out in Ancient China depended on the severity of the crime. For example, a prisoner’s face might be branded with certain marks based on the crime they had been convicted of, or they might be stripped of certain rights and privileges. In many cases, the offender’s family was also punished, even if the offender had already been killed.

One of the most infamous punishments used in Ancient China was the "death by a thousand cuts", or ling chi. Ling chi was used to slowly kill the offender by cutting through joints and muscles in the body. This horrific punishment was used as a warning to other potential criminals and was seen as a deterrent to crime. However, it was criticized as being barbaric and in 1905, as a result of a global outcry, it was officially outlawed in China.
Ran Zhao @ Unsplash

Despite the horror that ling chi engendered, the death penalty still had a significant role in the Chinese on justice system. It was used for a wide variety of offenses, such as rape, treason, murder, and even for petty offenses such as stealing. Additionally, even though the Chinese have abolished the death penalty for most offenses, it is still used for crimes such as trafficking in drugs, terrorism, and bribery.

One of the main questions surrounding the use of the death penalty in Chinese justice is whether or not it has been an effective deterrent. Unfortunately, there is no clear answer to this question and it has been much debated by academics. Some argue that the death penalty has not been effective in reducing crime rates, while others argue that it is impossible to make an absolute statement on the efficacy of the death penalty without knowing all the factors that contribute to the crime rates.
Peter Zhou @ Unsplash

At the same time, many argue that capital punishment should not be the default punishment for crime, and that the justice system should instead focus on rehabilitation, forgiveness, and creating an environment in which crime is less likely to occur. This argument is gaining traction in Chinese society and legal reform groups are advocating for a more compassionate and progressive approach to criminal justice.

The use of the death penalty in Chinese justice has a long and complicated history. While it has been a part of the legal code for thousands of years, it is clear that the punishment has evolved significantly and is now being used much more sparingly. It is also a controversial topic and there is much debate about its use, effectiveness, and legitimacy.